The legitimacy of any government is tested by its response to citizens demanding accountability. In Pakistan-administered Jammu and Kashmir, commonly referred to in India as Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (PoJK), the events unfolding since June 2026 have exposed a widening gulf between popular aspirations and Islamabad’s approach to governing the territory.
What initially emerged as a movement against economic hardship has evolved into a confrontation over political rights, institutional accountability and the limits of regional autonomy. The reported scale of civilian casualties has transformed a domestic political dispute into a human rights issue that warrants international scrutiny.
A mounting human toll
According to a communication reportedly addressed to the Pakistani government by six United Nations Special Rapporteurs on 4 September 2026, at least 96 protesters and six members of the police and paramilitary forces had lost their lives since demonstrations began in June. A significant proportion of the civilian victims were reportedly between the ages of 15 and 35.
The concerns attributed to the UN experts extend beyond the number of fatalities. They include allegations involving live ammunition, tear gas, physical violence, restrictions on telecommunications, arrests of journalists and political activists, and measures affecting more than 200 individuals.
Subsequent estimates attributed to the Jammu Kashmir Human Rights Organisation and local activists place the civilian death toll between 101 and 119, with more than 910 people reportedly injured.
Although these figures remain difficult to substantiate independently, the consistency of accounts emerging from local communities points to the need for a comprehensive examination of the conduct of Pakistan’s security forces.
Restrictions on access to information have made establishing an accurate record of events exceptionally difficult.
Controlling the narrative, even after death
Among the most disturbing allegations are those concerning the treatment of families seeking to recover the bodies of their relatives.
The Jammu Kashmir Human Rights Organisation reportedly documented the case of Fahad Barkat, whose family was allegedly required to sign a declaration identifying him as a terrorist killed during a police encounter before his remains could be returned.
When the family refused, the authorities reportedly proceeded with the burial themselves.
Similar allegations have emerged in other cases, including accounts attributed to the communication from the UN Special Rapporteurs.
If substantiated, such practices would represent a serious violation of human dignity and an attempt to impose an official interpretation of events upon bereaved families.
The issue extends beyond the right to conduct a funeral. By attaching the label of terrorism to individuals killed during demonstrations, the authorities risk depriving victims of public recognition while discouraging others from participating in political mobilisation.
The struggle over accountability therefore continues even after the deaths themselves.
How economic protests became a political confrontation
The origins of the current crisis lie in widespread dissatisfaction with declining living standards and the rising cost of essential commodities, particularly flour.
The Jammu Kashmir Joint Awami Action Committee (JAAC) emerged as a central organising force behind demonstrations that gradually expanded their agenda to include demands for greater political representation, administrative reforms and the release of detained activists.
Rather than addressing these grievances through sustained political dialogue, the Pakistani authorities reportedly moved to proscribe JAAC as a terrorist organisation, arrest its leadership and deploy additional security resources.
This development marked a decisive shift in the character of the crisis.
By placing a civilian protest movement within a counterterrorism framework, Islamabad effectively transformed a dispute over governance into a national security matter.
The distinction is fundamental. Legitimate security operations against armed groups cannot automatically justify exceptional measures against citizens exercising their rights to peaceful assembly and political participation.
The reported use of counterterrorism legislation against political mobilisation raises questions about whether such measures are compatible with Pakistan’s international human rights obligations.
The escalation of violence
The situation reportedly deteriorated considerably during the final days of July.
Clashes in Sudhnoti and Mathiyal Mera allegedly resulted in nine fatalities over a two-day period, bringing the reported death toll since June to approximately 30 at that stage.
Accounts emerging from the region also alleged that security personnel opened fire on unarmed demonstrators in Mirpur on 28 July. Further accusations concerned the removal of bodies and restrictions on access to a local hospital.
The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP), following a fact-finding mission in August, reportedly identified a combination of political grievances, economic insecurity, institutional distrust and failures of governance as the underlying drivers of instability.
Its findings, as presented in the available accounts, suggest that an increasingly confrontational state response and disproportionate use of force further weakened public confidence in the authorities.
Crucially, the commission was reportedly unable to establish the full extent of civilian casualties because it was denied access to Rawalakot, one of the principal centres of unrest.
Such restrictions undermine the credibility of official accounts and prevent victims from obtaining meaningful redress.
Islamabad’s security-first approach
The involvement of federal security formations alongside the local police has introduced another dimension to the confrontation.
Pakistan Rangers and personnel reportedly transferred from other provinces have reinforced the central government’s role in managing the unrest.
The authorities have also reported substantial casualties among security personnel. According to figures attributed to the regional police chief, 38 members of the security forces had been killed and 742 injured since June.
These allegations must also form part of any independent investigation. Casualties among security personnel, however, do not remove the obligation of the authorities to demonstrate that their use of force was lawful, necessary and proportionate.
The deployment of federal forces suggests that Islamabad increasingly views the unrest through the prism of internal security rather than as a manifestation of longstanding political and socioeconomic grievances.
Such an approach may temporarily suppress demonstrations, but it does little to address the conditions that produced them.
The contradictions of regional autonomy
The official designation of the territory as Azad Jammu and Kashmir — meaning Free Jammu and Kashmir — carries a political significance that stands in contrast to continuing disputes over the region’s constitutional and administrative status.
Despite its own political institutions, the territory operates within a governance framework in which Islamabad retains substantial influence. Critics also point to the role of Pakistan’s military establishment in shaping the broader security environment.
The protest movement challenges this distribution of authority by demanding greater accountability from the institutions responsible for regional governance.
The reported designation of JAAC as a terrorist organisation has intensified these concerns.
According to the supplied accounts, the UN Special Rapporteurs questioned the compatibility of the designation with international law.
The broader danger is that counterterrorism legislation may become an instrument for narrowing political space, restricting civil liberties and delegitimising opposition to established institutions.
The accountability vacuum
Perhaps the most consequential aspect of the crisis is the reported absence of an independent mechanism capable of establishing responsibility for the deaths and serious injuries.
The HRCP has reportedly called for an impartial investigation examining the conduct of security personnel and the circumstances surrounding each fatality.
Such an investigation would need unrestricted access to medical records, witnesses, affected communities and relevant official documentation. It would also have to examine allegations of unlawful detention, obstruction of medical assistance and coercion of victims’ families.
Communication restrictions and limitations on journalistic access have made independent verification particularly difficult.
Without transparency, competing casualty figures and conflicting accounts will continue to circulate, deepening mistrust and leaving families without reliable answers.
The Pakistani authorities should publicly address the concerns raised by international human rights mechanisms and facilitate independent scrutiny of the events.
Pakistan’s international credibility at stake
For decades, Pakistan has sought to position itself internationally as an advocate of the rights and political aspirations of Kashmiris.
The allegations emerging from the territory under its own administration pose a direct challenge to that diplomatic narrative.
A government cannot credibly demand international attention to human rights violations elsewhere while resisting independent scrutiny of its own conduct.
The immediate priorities should include an impartial investigation into civilian and security-force casualties, restoration of communications, unrestricted access for journalists and human rights observers, judicial review of the designation of JAAC, and the release of individuals detained solely for peacefully exercising their political rights.
The international community must apply consistent standards to human rights concerns across Kashmir, irrespective of which government administers the territory concerned.
Ultimately, the crisis is about far more than the price of flour or the ability of the authorities to contain public demonstrations. It concerns the relationship between political power and civil liberties, the right of communities to demand accountable governance, and the responsibility of the state to protect human life.
Silencing dissent cannot substitute for addressing its causes. Nor can restrictions on information erase the obligation to establish the truth.